As a child, I never thought I would keep my last name. My parents were not married when they had me. I was the intentional fruit of their love, an attempt to “stick it to the man” or rebel against mainstream society, or something of the sort. Thus, I was given the curse of the hyphenated name. Now, some combined last names can be lovely, but mine was neither lyrical nor easy to pronounce, especially by my own self, given my slight lisp, which hinders my enunciation. My middle name is the maiden name of my great-grandmother, who, as the story goes, was born when the boat docked, carrying her parents from France. I’ve always liked my middle name. It’s short. I can say it easily, with grace. I can’t remember when it was decided that when I became an adult I would drop my parents’ names and take my middle name as my surname, but this has been my understanding for as long as I can remember.
And then I married an historian. Andy comes from a long line of Risingers. They have family reunions every summer. They have special names for things (like those contraptions you use to keep your beer cold? You know, called “koozies” by the rest of us? Well, amongst the Risingers they’re called Darryls. No one even knows why). And I know that it matters immensely to my husband that his middle name is the same as his father’s, who had it passed down from his father. Yet, given the importance of tradition to the man I married, he never asked me to take his name. In fact, each time it’s come up, he’s clearly been against it. “I never thought my wife would take my last name,” he says simply. “I would never ask her to do that.” It turns out that Andy’s fear of what other people would think trumped his deeply rooted need that tradition be upheld. Given that on our first date he proudly pronounced himself a feminist, I shouldn’t have been surprised by his reaction. He scorns hype of any sort and has no patience for conformity. Yet, as stated above, he has a passion for history unlike anyone else I’ve ever met. Slightly contradictory? Yes. Confusing? Sometimes. Especially now, as with marriage comes the complicated choice of deciding how to proceed legally as well as publicly, now that we’re officially considered a unit in both the eyes of that state as well as all our loved ones. So here were the choices as we saw them:
A. Keep my hyphenated last name, retaining my connection to my parents
B. Drop my last name and legally adopt my middle name as my last name
C. Become a member of the Risinger clan
D. Find some way to combine all our names into a new amalgamation
My concerns were as follows:
I’ve been a hyphen my whole life up until this point and to be honest, I’m kind of sick of it. My parents both moved our here in the 70’s and we rarely saw our extended family. I don’t feel like a strong connection to either side. And I’m a little embarrassed to admit it but there’s the vanity issue. I LOVE Andy’s last name. It rolls off my tongue like honey. Plus, it originates from the German word for “traveler,” which I happen to think is awesome. And then there’s the clan. I’ve always wanted to be a part of something bigger than myself and the small house in which I grew up in. The idea of having an extended group of cousins, aunts, and uncles that I can belong to both excites and calms me. Yet as my dad so bluntly stated, “I didn’t raise a feminist daughter just so she could throw away everything we worked so hard for.” Ouch. Okay, so maybe it was said a little nicer than that, but that’s what it felt like. But I totally get where he’s coming from. I don’t want to lose my identity, nor do I want to let go of my connection to my family’s past, tenuous though it might be. And how weird is it that I can just become a new person overnight? I don’t like the idea that I’ll have to go through all this hassle and paperwork, while Andy’s identity remains unchanged. I’d like for him to somehow be legally and publicly altered as well, both because that seems fair in the logistical sense but more significantly, is important to me symbolically. But every combination we’ve tried sounds awkward, or silly, or worse, forced. And my middle name? Well, if you probe back far enough, well it’s still some woman’s husband’s name that she took in place of her own. Seems we just can’t take patriarchy out of the equation, no matter what we do. And the biggest issue for me is in regards to the children that we plan to have someday. Having been a teacher in the Bay Area for the past 8 years, I can tell you, I’ve seen every possibility under the sun. The hyphens I understand, but what happens when hyphens get married? Because three (or worse, four!) last names just seems ridiculous. And then there are those families where the mom keeps her last name and the children take the dad’s. Respectfully, that’s a big fat no in my book. That just makes me feel like an outsider, like I’m not a member of the club. So what then is a hippie raised feminist to do? Andy feels equally torn. He doesn’t want me to lose my own history, yet he’s not quite ready to adopt a completely new last name for himself.
And then we applied for our marriage license. And it came time to decide. Ultimately, the decision was up to me. Not my dad, and honestly, not even my husband. With a flourish of the pen and a smile, I decide to become an Risinger. Do I still question this? You betcha. But it comes down to this: all those other things do matter, for sure, but I want to be a family unit and that matters to me more than anything else. And knowing who my husband is, I can’t think of a greater gift than I can give than taking his name, even though he didn’t ask me to, especially because he didn’t ask me to. And dad? I didn’t throw it all away. I’m still a hyphen, and I will always be a hyphen, and even more importantly than that, you taught me to think carefully, to follow my heart, and make my own decision. And do you know what he said, when I whispered this to him on the dance floor at our wedding? Well, he squeezed me and said, “Strella, I may not agree with your decision, but I will always stand by you.” And that’s what really matters.